Have you done a search of a who's-Who's for each program? In other words, how many graduates are working in big jobs? Do a search for resumes, and the name of the college on Google? You wil find professors and other universities that went through the program? Keep an eye on where those people went to grad school.
Also take a look at the personal factors. Costs? Distance?
Also be aware that if you do choose one and you don't like, then transfer.
Hope that helps.