Welcome to the Booth, TheCo. Many of us share your affection for the re-use of "vintage" fixtures. (See
http://www.controlbooth.com/forums/lighting/6102-old-theatre-lights-can-useful.html for an, admittedly extreme, example.)
I can't find any information on the BSP lamp. But I have a 4.5" Kliegl #3604
Fresnel [1978 datasheet links to klieglbros.com:
Front,
Back.] whose faceplate lists a BSP, 200 hour, 500W lamp. Is this your
fixture?
Minus the lampshade, of course.
The lowest wattage, commonly available, G9.5
base lamp would be the 500W EHD, still too much for "decorative" use. Also, the
filament structure isn't really suited to the
spherical reflector of the
Fresnel, although mine has a slightly oval-shaped, 1.5"
reflector. I would consider replacing the
socket with a medium
screwbase (E27
socket) which would provide for a wide range of 25-100W lamps, and even
CFL or screw-in
LED lamps.