Part of me wants to laugh, because way back in the day before fancy digital boards that you could
cue, we had to balance all the mics with
mute buttons and faders, line-by-line was an imagined dream. I still prefer live mixing over letting the board do all the work because some nights some people are off, tired, or just plain
flat.
In my unprofessional opinion (because I’m unprofessional usually) use the hanging mics as reinforcement. They’ll never be as accurate or
dynamic as what a “lead” is wearing, but sometimes you can get some interesting parts and voices up over the leads that add to the show. On the flip side, sometimes you can get some lead voices that need to be “softened” a little, so being active on the faders, giving a bump here or there or dropping the mic a hair and USING YOUR EARS AND BRAIN can make the sound so much better.
I’ll still occasionally sit at the board with my
headphones on one ear so I can listen in to muted mics or solo out a mic to hear what we’re getting. Just because it sounded good at mic check doesn’t mean it’s going to be the same after act 1, and there have been beautiful parts that got buried because we didn’t hear them until we listened.