I love the 1k in small houses because I can put a 500w lamp in and it works great. At 1000w the
fixture is just too small to dissipate heat, sort of like 1000 watts in a 6x9, the
fixture just seems too hot, difficult to adjust (
safety, also materials expand with heat). Gels burn out quickly, the bases develop arcing problems,
etc.. Think people "hate" the 1k because they are used to finding it working too hard in spaces where it lacks the
power or punch to really be effective. Also it has the Toyota problem, where a well-made product endures long enough to still work even though most of its original functionality is severely impaired. Coming up to an unfamiliar 1k it is typical for the focus shaft to have deep scars from people moving the
unit without loosening the focus
bolt, the
zoom/spot lever is often sticky or broken entirely, the tilt clutch is loose,
etc.. Few of these are actually the
instrument's fault.
Your other questions can be roughly answered by researching product data sheets: "
Altman 360q Lumens" would be your first google search, then find the specs on the other fixtures. BTL is the code for 500w
Fresnel lamp, EHG is code for 750w 6x9 style. Double check on extant lamps, data sheets. Anecdotally on brightness, yes and no, the
Source Four has a clarity and precision to its optics that makes it seems "brighter". Their "black body curve" is more even, with greater transmission across all frequencies. With limited fixtures I would reserve the Source Fours for more saturated gels, gels tend to expose the flaws in the older ellipsoidals' optics.