For what it's worth (coming from both a theatrical and commercial/event production viewpoint) my list of "give it a try" would be:
(and no, I do not claim any of these to be 750w
HPL in a clean Source4 equivalent, but they'll kick on a 575w)
1) Chauvet Ovation, either white light only or the FC (color mixing) light - but use their optics not any left-over S4 lenses.
2)
ETC ColorSource
3)
ETC Lustr
4)
Altman PHX
That's based on my own hung-in-spaces experience. Two main caveats 1: theses are not color-matching to hot light+
gel, no matter how good the board's
gel picker is, always match by eye. 2: your existing inventory will influence how these lights look and perform when hung in a mixed-source
plot. Always do your homework and have the dealer set up a
fixture to
fixture shoot out.
Also, I'd say try to stay with big-name players just for the quality control of
LED emitter
binning from year to year. I remember back with some other vendors when the red or blue end of the
fixture shifted the center
point of the color by a few hundred nm.