Dunno what JD is talking about specifically with his
frost gel comment, but in thousands of video productions I don't think I have ever handled a
frost gel...
But I digress.
You can use the S4 fresnels with care.
Video needs that flood setting to have a resonable linearity of
intensity across the pool of light generated. Your light
meter should be informative...
(Reason #1 why
PAR cans for Video are less than ideal. That hot centric football is almost impossible to work around....)
What you need is some
grip equipment (C-stands w/long arms, sandbags,
etc.), and a box of flags either 12x24 or preferably 24x36 (2 singles, 2 doubles, 1 silk, 1
screen cookie, 2 gobos).
The flags (singles, doubles, silks, cookies,
etc) will let you control the flavor of the light while preserving the qualities you need.
For instance: If you set up a key/fill/hair/bg basic rig with 4 of the same
intensity S4Fs, you can leave the key open and put a double on the fill and a pair of doubles on the hair and whatever
screen cookie came with your flag kit to break up the background with maybe a contrasty
gel clipped to it...
You will have a nice "nose break" to show that the person has depth, they will have a relative gradient across the scene and the hair light will seperate the talent from the BG.
All of this adds the sense of depth to a two dimensional medium.
If you light it just soft everywhere it will look
flat and lifeless. (many recent productions have this
flat (awful)
effect for no reason other than being lazy...)
If you are trapped with soft-bag or MR softlights you have to have pretty vast
intensity differences to give the scene any depth. Like a 1K key and a 500 or 250W fill...
If you cannot get access to a set of flags, tough spun is a substitute, but you have to be careful... 1/8 and 1/4 TS are more than satisfactory to throttle and soften the fill and hair...
Your mileage may vary.