JD
Well-Known Member
As a large proponent of LED lighting for use in general area lighting (house lights) as well as domestic lighting, I was curious when I found a site called "Ban LED Lighting." ( https://banledlighting.wordpress.com/ ) I figured it was some nut-case site of misinformation, but I always like to hear the other side of issues, so I gave it a look.
Many of the topics raised I think we are all aware of, such as; Poor dimming, minimum loads, CRI, heat issues, Toxic issues, etc.. Still, there were a number of topics that were interesting, such as; Recall information, shock hazards, fire hazards, RF pollution, etc. Bottom line, I am still a proponent of LED lighting and any reasonable installation would take all these factors into consideration. I have some debate in my mind regarding toxic contributions as they are far better (less toxic) than CLF lamps, but more so than an old incandescent lamp. I think that LEDs would fit more into the category of cell phone and other general electronic recycling. I would give the articles a read, although like myself, you will probably find yourself dismissing most of the points raised.
Many of the topics raised I think we are all aware of, such as; Poor dimming, minimum loads, CRI, heat issues, Toxic issues, etc.. Still, there were a number of topics that were interesting, such as; Recall information, shock hazards, fire hazards, RF pollution, etc. Bottom line, I am still a proponent of LED lighting and any reasonable installation would take all these factors into consideration. I have some debate in my mind regarding toxic contributions as they are far better (less toxic) than CLF lamps, but more so than an old incandescent lamp. I think that LEDs would fit more into the category of cell phone and other general electronic recycling. I would give the articles a read, although like myself, you will probably find yourself dismissing most of the points raised.