I just want to point out that while this has been a lively discussion. The original post said the budget was tight, hoping to maybe spend $2000. That budget rules out just about every option mentioned except the PC options. The quesiton isn't which style is better, the question is getting the most bang for your buck. When you look at it that way, the PC approach is outstanding. These program have brought the advanced functionality of a great light console down to a price that most can afford. Yeah it can feel a little awkward getting used to, but there's no comparison when you look at it from a functionality on a budget point of view.
Have fun with Lightjockey, it's good software.
Have fun with Lightjockey, it's good software.