Okay, I'll bite. Why NOT use a
power screwdriver to assist in the task of
turning the screw(s)? Then finish with a standard
driver.
What IS the manufacturer's specification regarding the torque setting for inner terminals,
strain-relief, and cover-plate screws on a
Union Connector or
Bates 2P&G-20A
connector? I've never seen this information; granted last time I installed connectors was a few years ago, but the 2P&G s came individually wrapped (like Kraft Singles) in a
clear plastic bag. No instructions enclosed for this
UL-Listed apparatus.
http://www.controlbooth.com/threads/wiring-extension-cables.35789/page-2#post-310800
(What is the proper torque setting for 2P&G-20A?
Interesting that this subject has arisen, as I've just learned a major company with multiple shows here in Las Vegas requires the use of a torque screwdriver when installing
power
connectors. The person quoted a specific setting, but couldn't tell me where it came from.
I'm pretty sure
ETC
's (and others') assembly dept. is not turning all the screws on all their connectors by
hand
.
Thanks for any input,
Derek)
I’m certain that
ETC is using
crimp plugs so that’s a non-starter for the most part, they might do screw type plugs if asked to, but you would have to ask them. (Factory crimped plugs are also a bad thing - means a one time only use of the
plug you paid for.)
Tough enough to get employees to buy their own basic
hand tools, much less quality ones. What you mean the 3/16" slotted blade tip won’t do for the
terminal on an
Edison plug? And at times noting someone using a [HASHTAG]#1[/HASHTAG] Phillips tip type stuff. I would consider a torque wrench or screw
driver to be something beyond a normal employee owned thing to provide. Even I don’t own a torque wrench - though I have one for CamLoc and another for 60A
stage in my tool box, than many more in the shop tool box including
socket torque adaptors that are pre-set and not adjustable. If the company provides such tools, than that is a whole different mandate and could be enforced. Otherwise with a torque screw
driver, there is various brands and qualities of them out there - how does one ensure calibration this much less people tensioning until it clicks?
Easy enough to determine an in-house shop specific torque setting for a 20a
stage pin plug screw
terminal somewhere between the flow
point of the metal and too loose. Might even be a specific torque setting in the instructions for the
plug - don’t remember but very possible to
cover legal type liability. I know I use that specified torque setting for 60a
stage pin plugs and used to every year open up every
plug and re-tension them, but we don’t use 5Kw Fresnels that much any longer in checking these days.
Even with a
ferrule and proper torque tension on a 60a
stage pin plug, re-torqeing of the
plug every year saves it from melt down. Properly crimped
ring terminal type plugs if lock washer used is not necessary if the screw was installed properly.
Even on a 30A
plug tensioned as hard as one can, re-tensioning of the terminals is often required after initial installation.
Wire expands and contracts under high amperage load and once settled it will now be loose until heated up enough to expand again at best in proper tension - this causes resistance and can damage the
plug. Really hard to get back to re-tension a cable after initial use in a large shop, best one can do is the rattle test... if it rattles it’s loose.
Stage pin plugs rattle by way of construction so that test is useless on them.
Can also be an argument on torque setting on
circuit breakers and Marathon blocks for this concept of proper torque setting. Some manuals require I think a re-tension of the
terminal to torque after full loading. Also impossible to get done so you over-tighten or as tight as you can and hope it all works out.
Have not other than for small projects, tensioned the brass screws on a
stage pin by
hand for years. Used to use a 3.6v Panasonic cordless screwdriver, than switched to a 7.2v DeWalt later. No
power tool other than a corded one is ensured of providing the proper torque clutch setting on a
terminal, and that than depends on the user. Depends on angle of
bit, wear on the
bit, pressure on the screw, speed, battery life and how warn the clutch is. Got two cordless drills currently in the factory repair shop due to clutch problems.
I do use cordless screwdrivers though for doing plugs - can fabricate hundreds of cables a day with their use and I have made or supervised the fabrication of thousands of
stage pin plugs amongst many other types. All tools I use for this have a blade lock and we still follow the policy of 1/4 turn past
hand tight for such brass screws or as hard as you can get for others. In this case, we have the clutch set for tension, than twist the drill afterwards to manually finish tensioning the screw. This or dependant on the
terminal and project
switch to a 1/4" or larger
flat heat screw
driver to do the final tension.
1/4 Turn past
hand tight is my policy but is dependant on an agreement of what is
hand tight. For me, it’s a policy of - I don’t care who you are or how much experience you have, unless me or someone I have trained has tested what your tension is you don’t get to install or fix plugs. This at least in the shop as best I can enforce. Was a lot easier years ago in a smaller company and where people were filtered
thru my department for training. For the most part though... everyone is in theory trained properly except for the free lancers that I cannot do too much about. Often have more problems with strip length overall than loose screws, though I even by "trained" people at times find problems with tension.
It’s almost impossible to ensure everyone anywhere will do quality work. The requirement of a torque screwdriver might be a management
level "fix" to poor workmanship we all live with. "Ferrules, I don’t have any so I will just shove the
wire in" type workmanship. Such a requirement if true from some shop I would hope is provided, and everyone using it is trained in the use of it. Kind of simplistic solution to a basic wiring problem though. If one provides the tool, and trains one in the use of it, one doesn’t really need to provide the tool in that the person trained already will tension the screw
terminal properly with or without a torque setting. Someone that isn’t properly trained in the use of the tool and or
plug cannot be assured of properly tensioning the screw anyway so why give them one?